Sunday, March 17, 2024

WRONG WAY ROUND


It has long been obvious to me that I am wildly out of sympathy with the contemporary world and that I harbour many dated attitudes and expectations. I ascribed much of this to old age and general geriatric irritability but I now realise that the world I once knew, the liberal-democratic West, is indeed breaking up rapidly, if it is not already broken. A last-minute jailbreak, as in a Hollywood action movie, is required before the process is irreversible! OMG!


             Wanton Russian destruction in Ukraine

What are we to make of the following list of recent peculiar absurdities?

(1)    Harry Potter author J K Rowling is in apparent danger of being prosecuted for denying transsexual broadcaster India Willoughby’s assertion that “he” is a woman.

(2)    King Charles is pressed to apologise to Prince Harry for mistreating him in his youth and undermining Meghan Markle’s position in royal circles.

(3)    Britain is expected to eat humble pie and pay huge reparations to Caribbean nations for the historic institution of Slavery in the 16th to 18th Centuries.

(4)    The unelected UK House of Lords seeks to frustrate all attempts by the UK government to deport illegal immigrants or fly them to Rwanda for assessment.

(5)    The discredited Metropolitan Police manage to arrest a demonstrator waving a sign saying “Hamas are Terrorists” - pro-Hamas demonstrators in their thousands are untouched.

(6)     British Jews live in fear of violence from Islamist fanatics and their Leftist supporters on the streets of London. The MP for Golders Green (Mike Freer) is standing down due to intimidation.

(7)    US Presidential candidate Donald Trump praises Putin (“genius” and “savvy”) and privately speaks well of Xi and Hitler. He leads in all the polls.

(8)    Pope Francis enrages Ukraine by advising her to wave the white flag and negotiate peace with Russia to end the war.

(9)    Chinese influences and money stifle debate about that country’s aggressive policies and repression of dissenters.

(10)                        UK media and advertisers continue to peddle the myth that Britain has very substantial black and Asian minorities. The 2021 census figures are a mere 4% and 9% respectively.


      Pro-Palestinian demos in the streets of London

All the above are examples of the distortions of thinking and erratic behaviour prevalent in the West, weakening its hard-won Liberties and dimming the warm glow of our Enlightenment.

Going back to first principles, most Britons believe in toleration, giving much latitude to a wide range of opinions. People should be able to express their views in any way, within certain limits. Those limits forbid the use of violence or intimidation or expressions of racial, sectarian or tribal hatreds. We have built a long-established system of parliamentary democracy which must change with the times, but preferably gradually and with a broad measure of electoral and public support. The judiciary must apply the law with integrity and be uninfluenced by political pressures.


    

                                         “Activist” vandalizes Balfour portrait at Cambridge University

The problem of social disintegration in the West, viewed from my admittedly geriatric ivory tower, is that our society has lost its moral compass. But I am truly talking about people who have no moral compass and to whom “morality” is a mere joke. How can we explain a cash economy to avoid VAT, practiced by every tradesman, too many politicians “on the make” in US, UK and Europe grasping at bribes, or ruthless company directors gaily committing grand larceny as if it were their “entitlement”? Where does morality sit with those civil servants and academics who “cancel” all dissenting voices with unrelenting malice, and are complicit in the distortion of historical fact?

To be sure, we in the West need to reset our priorities. It is too easy to blame governments in office. Rishi Sunak is an honourable fellow but his country has tired of his party. Joe Biden is too old, but who isn’t? Macron, Scholz and Meloni may be somewhat uninspiring, but new leaders are just outside the door, - the West has so much in its favour. It may not have the manpower of China and Russia, but the West has the brains, the technology and the resources to overcome all her foes.


The West’s priorities, not unlike those at the start of the Cold War, are rearmament and advanced technology. Her industrial work-forces need to be mobilised and energetically managed. Climate targets, high welfare payments, triple locks, unaffordable health services and immigration policies will have to take a back seat meanwhile or be drastically reformed.

Our large educated elites, need to show our people the way forward, to lead, galvanise and inspire. Step forward now!

 

 

SMD

17.03.24

Text copyright © Sidney Donald 2024

Saturday, February 3, 2024

WRITERS OF CONSEQUENCE


In my old age, I think of the books that have radically influenced me. To give some context, I am a conventional fellow, bourgeois, financially privileged, with a vaguely Presbyterian background, intellectually curious up to a point, but British to the core with tastes limited to the English-speaking world with smatterings from some European power-houses. I confess I am not an innovator, lateral thinker nor original spirit. So be warned!

I list the books in chronological publication date order, though I certainly did not read them in that order;

1.       Buddenbrooks by Thomas Mann (1901). Because I had a family biz background, I understood this saga of the decline and fall over 4 generations of a thriving business in Lübeck, (cf. Succession on Amazon Prime). Mann was a serious writer and sometimes I struggled with his complexity. His last work, The Confessions of Felix Krull (1954) showed that he had that famously elusive German sense of humour.

 

2.       Strait is the Gate by André Gide (1909). A very tender love-story of the doomed devotion of cousins Jerome and Alissa, whose impossibly high, puritanical standards cannot be achieved.  Mainly told through exchange of letters, this is a marvellous piece. Gide was a dominant and astringent French intellectual for 40 years.

 

3.       Journey to the End of the Night (1932) by Louis-Ferdinand Céline. This racy saga of poverty in Paris, the experiences of a doctor, work in the American motor industry, was highly original and brilliant in 1932. Céline in 1940 became notorious as a collaborationist and antisemite, a decidedly bad egg all round. He died in 1961, returning to France unprosecuted, after voluntary exile in Denmark.

 

Andre Gide


Kingsley Ami

 

4.       The Grapes of Wrath (1939) by John Steinbeck. This is a very moving family chronicle of the Joads, driven from dust bowl Oklahoma to ruthless exploitation and starvation as labourers in California. A bible for Lefties, it stirred the conscience of and fired indignation into a generation of Americans. Steinbeck wrote widely but never equalled this masterpiece.

 

 

5.       The Power and the Glory by Graham Greene (1940). This tale of a lone whiskey-priest’s persecution in rural Mexico, is typical of Greene’s ardent Catholicism and foresight, championing traditional beliefs against the cruelties of ideological atheism. The priest accepts his martyrdom with shaky dignity. Striking but somewhat depressing.

 

6.       L’Etranger (The Outsider) by Albert Camus (1942). This short novel is arresting from its first lines. “Mother died today. Or maybe yesterday. I can’t be sure”. Camus’ protagonist in Algeria, proclaims his liberation from life’s norms, is condemned for accidently shooting an Arab man. He awaits execution with Olympian contempt for his persecutors. What a book!

 

 

7.       The Master of Santiago by Henri de Montherlant (1947). This taut drama was an A Level French set book giving a taste of masochistic Spanish Catholic devotion. Montherlant was an influential writer of the Right, a tortured soul, who, knowing his declining powers, in 1972 entertained his friends for lunch and then shot himself. Andre Malraux, Gaullist minister of Culture praised Montherlant’s irrepressible independence of spirit.

 

8.       Brideshead Revisited by Evelyn Waugh (1945). This evocation of eccentric 1920’s Oxford and the friendship of Charles Ryder with aristocratic Sebastian Flyte is highly civilized as is its treatment of the declining Marchmain family and its crumbling values. This is Waugh in his maturity, his earlier novels being an acquired taste, not helped by his abrasive personality.

 

9.       1984 by George Orwell (1949). This is a great dystopian, if satirical, novel where the protagonist Winston Smith, a low-level official at the Ministry for Truth, rewrites the historical record to the orders of Big Brother. We encounter familiar contemporary bogey-men like the Thought Police, brainwashing and all-powerful governments. A highly relevant cautionary tale for 2024!

 

Gore Vidal

 
Evelyn Waugh

10.   The Catcher in the Rye by J D Salinger (1951). At last, wartime gloom and post-war nightmares were dissipated by life-affirming Holden Caulfield and his hilarious adventures and misadventures in love and adolescence in dynamic America. It was the tonic we desperately needed - I read it aged 14 and never looked back with any Angst. Thank you, Salinger.

 

11.   Lucky Jim by Kingsley Amis (1954). This furious comic assault on the pettiness of academic life in a red-brick UK university, on the class system generally, and an eloquently misanthropic punch at a variety of human types is side-splittingly funny. Kingsley Amis later became excessively conservative – many preferred his son Martin Amis’ novels – but I stick with Kingsley.

 

12.   Giovanni’s Room by James Baldwin (1956). This book explores the gay infatuation of an American in Paris for a barman. It is extremely well-written with honesty and candour, about 10 years before its time. Baldwin went on to write his searing collection of essays, The Fire next Time, (1963), which discussed the race issue in America with urgent passion.

 

13.   Who’s afraid of Virginia Woolf? By Edward Albee (1962) was an explosive stage play and later a memorable film. I saw the play in London in 1964 and was astounded by its depiction of the dysfunctional marriage of George and Martha. The bitter but often deeply comic exchanges electrified the audience. I remember being taken to task for expressing my admiration at an interview. “Isn’t it very destructive? I was asked. Well, I suppose it was, but it was incomparable theatre.

 

14.   Myra Breckinridge by Gore Vidal (1968). This brilliant satire, defying all convention, has Myra as dominatrix of uncle Buck Loner, various scabrous sub-plots and after a car accident, Myra has a sex-change to become Myron. Not family reading, I admit, but I laughed like a drain at Vidal’s wit and invention.

 

I suppose if my list is ever analysed I will be diagnosed as a misogynistic, crypto-Catholic gay, but I do not think that is accurate. Literature often shocks and we need that to stimulate and move on.  Do your own lists of whatever category and see where it leads!

SMD

2/02/24

Text Copyright © Sidney Donald 2024

Wednesday, January 17, 2024

GIMME THAT OLD TIME RELIGION!


It finally came on the eve of the Iowa caucuses.  A video emanating from the Trump camp claimed that God had sent Trump as his “caretaker” to manage the nation and the world; Trump is now a fully equipped crackpot American politician with his monstrous deal-doing ego supplemented with a solemn Messianic mission - to the evangelicals he is obviously unbeatable. Praise the Lord!

We have seen it all before. In 1925, populist 3-times presidential candidate William Jennings Bryan denounced the teaching of evolution in the famous Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee. Bryan was badly mauled under cross-examination and died shortly after the trial. H L Mencken summed it all up with characteristic verve.:

W J Bryan

One day the defence lured Bryan into his astounding argument against the notion that man is a mammal. I am glad I heard it, for otherwise I’d never believe it. There stood a man who had been thrice a candidate for the Presidency of the Republic, uttering stuff a boy of eight would laugh at….He came into life a hero, a Galahad, in bright and shining armour. He was passing out a poor mountebank.

May the same fate overwhelm Donald C Trump!

Religiosity (excessive religiousness) is one of the most off-putting facets in American life to the British and European cast of mind. We have mostly moved forward from defining our lives in religious terms, some generations ago.

Billy Graham (1918-2018) was a hugely successful US Southern Baptist evangelist who thrived mainly in the 1950s -70s. He filled stadia, ran crusades and preached cooperation. He was certainly a talented orator and he made friends with the good and the great. Eisenhower, Lyndon Johnson and maybe surprisingly Richard Nixon hung by his words and sought his counsel.  


Billy Graham

He was followed by a variety of black preachers, notably esteemed Martin Luther King, and Al Sharpton is still around, agitating at the first sign of trouble.

Britain has a tradition of sorts notably on the Celtic fringes, Ireland has long been a religious hotbed (some of this reflected in Joe Biden’s stubborn Anglophobia) and Ulster sported the anachronistic figure of the Rev Ian Paisley – ye shall hate idolators with an undying hate, he bellowed, although he mellowed later when he was forced to share power genially with “reformed” IRA gunman Martin MacGuinness. Scotland long had a bitter Protestant/Catholic divide but our current first minister Humza Yousaf seems most engrossed in the Palestinian cause. He is Scottish-born, raised as a Catholic but converted to Islam in 1977. His rival in the SNP, Kate Forbes, is a talented Gaelic-speaking 33-year-old, who has been finance minister. She is an adherent of the Wee Free Church, with only about 10,000 members, opposed to same-sex marriage and generally Puritanical and socially highly conservative. Karl Marx got much wrong but he was surely right in saying; Religion is the Opium of the People.


SNP's Kate Forbes

        

Moving on to terra firma from these ghostly matters, I have been puzzled by the differences between London attitudes and those of England more widely. Much of the difference derives from ethnic background. The London ethnic split according to the 2021 census is:

White British    36.8

Other White      17.0                 53.8%

Asian British    20.8

Black British     13.5

Mixed race       5.7

Other                 6.2                 46.2%

Note that White British are far from a majority even in their capital city.

Much more representative are the statistics for England and Wales from the same census.

White British    74.4

Other White      6.2                  80.6%

Asian British    9.3

Black British    4.0

Mixed race       2.9

Other               3.2                  19.4%

 

Viewed nationally, White British are in a substantial majority, as one might expect.

Last night I watched quiz night on BBC 2 (the BBC being reliably cutting edge on the betrayal of our country in my view). I enjoyed Mastermind, Only Connect and University Challenge compered skillfully by Clive Myrie, Victoria Coren Mitchell and Amol Rajan. These three are excellent and I am all for a meritocracy in broadcasting.

Yet I felt there was an elephant in the room. Let’s have Diversity but where are the Englishmen, the John Bull - Toby Jug- pub dartboard – Morris dancing Englishmen? Remember that statistic above, 74.4% no less. They may not be hugely talented in global terms but they deserve better in their own country than sink schools, useless public services, poor healthcare and crime-ridden streets. Let there be positive discrimination on their behalf, proper preparation for the world of work, a welcome to our better universities and their opportunities, the prospect of a decently paid career.

It is not too much to ask if we put our minds to it!

 

SMD

16.1.24

Text Copyright Sidney Donald 2024

Wednesday, January 10, 2024

LADIES FIRST

 

I tip-toe around this subject, as I have no wish to revive the battle of the sexes, and anyhow, half the world’s population is female and we all know how wonderful and talented most of them are.

From Cleopatra to the Hapsburg Empress Elizabeth (“Sissi”) and to Queen Victoria, ladies have enchanted and inspired us men, but it is only relatively recently that they have actually been in charge of affairs. We remember our past admiration for Golda Meir, Indira Gandhi, Benazir Bhutto and above all our revered idol Maggie Thatcher, who saved the UK



                         Romy Schneider as Sissi (1955)

But there has been a noticeable decline in wholly positive vibes in more recent years. Starting at the top in the UK, the esteemed Elizabeth II’s female successors include Charles’ Queen Camilla, Princess Kate and Andrew’s Duchess Fergie. All of them carry past baggage of varying weight and I cannot see the population warming to them easily.

 Some recent figures have been much more controversial. I am thinking of Angela Merkel (too tolerant of Russia), Liz Truss (a 30-day disaster), Hilary Clinton (losing even to Trump), Nicola Sturgeon (resigning as first Minister of Scotland in murky circumstances) and Jacinda Arden (New Zealand’s Queen of Woke). It is perhaps too early to take a dogmatic line - History will judge.

There are plenty aspiring ladies in the UK – Penny Mordaunt, Kemi Badenoch for the Tories, Angela Raynor and Rachel Reeves for Labour, not to mention US Presidential hopeful Nikki Hayley. But these people have not really been tested in very high office and only then can we judge their mettle.

The fact is that several high-flying ladies in the UK and US have come down with a bump recently:

1.       Alison Rose, Chief Executive of NatWest Bank. She broke her bank’s first requirement for client confidentiality by babbling to a reporter about the “de-banking” of right-wing politician Nigel Farage. Maybe her actions were animated by a compound of arrogance and political bias but Farage raised a stink and Rose lost her job.

 

2.       Paula Vennells, once head of the UK Post Office who presided over a grave miscarriage of justice affecting more than 700 employed as sub postmaster/postmistresses often in small town or village locations. The Post Office introduced in the late 1990s a new computer system bought from Fujitsu called Horizon. The cash would not balance in some cases, but the PO insisted there was nothing wrong and prosecuted many sub-postmasters with theft. Some suffered imprisonment, all lost their jobs and reputations. By 2010, it was discovered that Horizon had a computer glitch causing the imbalance. Quite when the PO management knew this, what they did about it, and how and when they advised ministers is not clear. Vennells has returned her CBE and apologised but that will hardly be enough. The luckless taxpayer will have to bear very high costs and the present Tory government has proposed a £600,000 compensation payment each to those affected. Senior PO officials and Fujitsu are being implicated, and in a delicious twist, LibDem leader, holier-than-thou Sir Ed Davey, is facing calls to resign. He was the Minister for Posts for 2 years and predictably did precisely nothing. Watch this space!

 

3.       Sharon White. Ended her term as chief executive of John Lewis, of department store and supermarket (Waitrose) fame. She is blamed for poor performance in an admittedly difficult sector, but critics say she drove a cherished brand into the ground with her misjudged policies.

 

4.       Claudine Gay. Appointed President of Harvard 5 months ago, she has been accused of several cases of academic plagiarism. Then she gave evasive evidence, along with the presidents of MIT and the University of Pennsylvania, to a congressional committee about campus antisemitism. They refused to condemn calls for the genocide of the Jews, to public outrage. All 3 presidents have now had to resign. In her resignation statement, Gay airily stated she would return to her old academic duties at Harvard. The US has some peculiar rules about academic tenure and entitlement, but Gay has done serious damage to Harvard’s reputation.  I expect the new President of Harvard to throw her out on her ear.

 

What do these 4 cases prove? We may feel some unworthy Schadenfreude (pleasure at the misfortune of others) but that is inappropriate. 


Alison Rose

    

                                                       Claudine Gay

These cases simply prove that Women are as prone to error and misjudgment as Men. To that extent we are all truly equal (at least in the West), which is the conclusion we want to proclaim.

Don’t worry, Ladies, we love you more than ever!

 

SMD

10.01.24

Sunday, January 7, 2024

 

A Rosy Crystal Ball

I thought it would be appropriate to take a positive forward view of 2024 and make some, maybe optimistic, political predictions. I do warn you that I do not have a spotless record as a prophet (I thought Boris’ first ministry would last for years) and you, my dear readers, will have their own ideas about the future. Anyway, I adopt the mantle of the soothsayers Nostradamus, Dr Faustus or is it, Cassandra?

1.       United Kingdom.

I expect the 2024 general election will be narrowly won by Labour. Efficient Sunak’s Tories will make some progress on the economy and immigration, but the electorate want change. Keir Starmer will become PM but he will be in an uneasy coalition with the swivel-eyed LibDems, constantly sniped at by the radical Left. Various other groups, SNP, Greens and Reform will make a nuisance of themselves. Starmer is a straight-forward lawyer but he is wooden, and completely lacks political nous or charisma.

The Tories will eventually re-align towards the centre, Right-wing ginger groups will wither as frankly Home Counties Tories are becoming apathetic. Rishi Sunak will not last long as, like Starmer he is worthy but not remotely inspirational. I guess he will be succeeded by Kemi Badenoch, a no-nonsense right-leaning lady of professional Nigerian parentage, but born in England. She has been an effective trade minister and is married to banker Hamish Badenoch (sounds Scottish but he actually hails from Northern Ireland). She will have many attractions for women, long-suffering committed Tories and first-generation immigrants.


Thoughtful Kemi Badenoch

2.       USA

The election that really matters is the American Presidential Election on Tuesday 5 November 2024. At present, everyone assumes it will be a dismal re-run of the 2020 election between Joe Biden and Donald Trump. I do not believe either candidate will run. Joe Biden, is a very ordinary machine politician who has never uttered a memorable word in his life. Soon his family and confidantes will have a quiet word with Sleepy Joe and tactfully tell him he is much too old, long past his sell-by date, put him to bed and turn off the lights. Some brighter (a low bar) Democratic senator or governor will win the nomination.

Nor will Donald Trump be running. He faces business ruin, numerous law-suits and reputational disgrace, mainly emanating from his deplorable encouragement of the Capitol riot of January 2021. The Americans protect their Constitution and Trump went too far. Trumpism (Make America Great Again etc.) is strong among the red-necks and less educated in the electorate and the Republicans will win having nominate the likes of Ron DeSantis, governor of Florida, who would be infinitely preferable to the ghastly Trump himself.

 



Ron DeSantis, a better man

3.       European Union

The EU proceeds in its sclerotic and imperialistic way, divided, quarrelsome and far less potent than it should be. With Poland and Hungary out-of-step it needs major reform. I foresee a 2-speed EU with the Slavs, Greeks and maybe Iberians in the slow lane. The initiative will move to France, Germany, Benelux, Italy, Austria, Denmark and Sweden who will speed up decision making, crucially integrate their economies and create a comprehensive banking system. Those with strong economies will make the EU a power-house again. The rest will toddle about to their own agendas, some may be admitted to the stronger group after a generation.

4.       The Rest of the World

One can only look with sadness at the mess in Ukraine, Gaza and the Middle East generally – predictions are beyond me. No doubt India, China and Japan will prosper (I do not think China will dare invade Taiwan). For most people all these issues pass them by, and in the time-honoured fairy-tale phrase - May they live happily ever after!

 

SMD

O7.01.24

Text copyright © Sidney Donald 2024

Saturday, December 23, 2023

THE YEAR COMES TO AN END....


2023 will soon be coming to an end, full of momentous events in the big wide world, not many of them very inspiring, and much chat from cherished friends and family as we inexorably grow older and we become even more confused by the modern world and the weird attitudes of the 21st century. It is a period to count one’s blessings, seek forgiveness, sturdily philosophise and wax lyrical about any high-points.


                                Edward Elgar (1857-1934)

To set the mood, I suggest a bucketful of Elgar – with his incomparable Cello Concerto, evoking a tranquil England, with its timeless beauty. Xavier Phillips and The Seattle Symphony do the business.

https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=youtube+elgar+cello+concerto#fpstate=ive&vld=cid:c8517917,vid:d44DbNQ81cM,st:0

Of course, much of England and the wider UK is far from tranquil. In its schools, its universities and in its work-places there is a culture war waging of great intensity and bitterness. Fundamentally, talented immigrants are supplanting duller native whites, not just for the top jobs but for any job. Some quotes from triumphant “inclusive” recruitment executives have been positively blood-curdling, divisive and ominous – a recipe for future conflict. May wiser heads prevail!

Thinking of happier things, I have always loved the 18th century and within that, the style of Rococo. In search of balance and beauty, I will, even as an unbeliever, cherish devotional music of the period like the Stabat Mater by G B Pergolesi, composed as a commission from a pious Neapolitan confraternity (1735). The passage Sancta Mater, istud agas, is particularly fine and I attach a video of the performance in the iconic Rococo Frauenkirche in Dresden, sung beautifully by the Russian diva, Anna Netrebko, soprano, and the Italian mezzo, Marianne Pizzolato.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjOug5Z5aZk&ab_channel=ThePrestigiosoGaston

At the year-end one takes stock. As one gets decidedly old, we realise that the years take their solemn toll. Old friends pass on and we are inevitably diminished. We are rueful about failing to say all we ought to have said before dear friends and relatives are gone forever. Such regrets are natural but not productive; always look forward, seldom look back is an achievable motto. The world moves on quickly – my beliefs and attitudes, however much I defend them, belong to a past generation. Do not allow the modern world to slip away from your grip!

In conclusion, I evoke the memory of some old soldiers and I pay tribute to their courage and devotion to duty. Some were quite modest – a chauffeur who never forgot comrades burnt grievously in the assault on Anzio in 1944 – a cinema manager who was a sergeant in the Scots Guards and always walked in a military way. The pride of Willie Whitelaw, Maggie Thatcher’s great supporter, when his Scots Guards drove off the Argentines from Mount Tumbledown in the Falklands in 1982. Gallant old Harold MacMillan, who insisted that the slow march of his Grenadier Guards – Scipio by Handel – be played at his funeral. I say “Hurray for Colonel Blimp!”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFMM9rjL8XA&ab_channel=Somefolk

 

SMD

22.12.23

Text Copyright © Sidney Donald 2023

Monday, December 11, 2023

SIX SOLID CITIZENS


     Politicians are deeply unpopular these days throughout the democratic world, as our economies struggle and the pace of change demands rapid action - not easy for most systems. Britain is much affected by this malaise and admittedly the political talent-pool is not deep; but I here pay tribute to 6 politicians who are by no means universally cherished, but who are “consequential” in that they have got things done and have influenced the lives of many of their fellow-citizens in a positive fashion. My selection is fairly wide and I have tried to suppress my personal prejudices!

1.     Michael Gove

 



 

I do not cite Michael Gove, now 56, just because he is Scottish or that, like me, he was born into the purple of the Aberdeen commercial classes. He is the adopted son of an ultimately struggling Aberdeen fish processor, but he has the Protestant work-ethic to a marked degree and has marked out a varied and fruitful political career. He won a scholarship at Robert Gordon’s College and then read English at Lady Margaret Hall, Oxford. Moving from Labour to the Conservatives, he developed his eloquence at the Oxford Union and succeeded Boris Johnson as President of the Union in 1988, a pinnacle of undergraduate achievement.

Rejected when applying for a job at Conservative Central Office, he worked in Fleet Street rather obscurely before joining the Aberdeen Press and Journal (275 years old now) honing his skills before finding his niche as a leader writer and later columnist at The Times. He married the well-known journalist Sarah Vine in 2001, divorcing in 2022.

Entering Parliament in 2005, he quickly climbed the greasy pole, becoming a friend of David Cameron and his set, shadowing Ed Balls. He has had a succession of Cabinet offices, Education Secretary, Chief Whip, Justice Secretary, Environment Secretary, Duchy of Lancaster and Cabinet Office, and finally Levelling-Up Secretary. The portfolios hardly matter as Gove developed into a kind of Pooh-Bah without the arrogance, the Tory fixer who would get things done. In education he broke the dead hand of local authorities over state schools, by introducing independent Academies and other free schools and he drastically revised syllabuses, concentrating on traditional basics, much to the ire of the educational establishment. At the tricky Levelling-Up ministry he has subsidised local businesses and infrastructure projects, created several free-ports and even pushed the ENO to move to Manchester.

Yet to me, Gove’s finest hour was as one of the 3 Brexit leaders with Johnson and Farage. Gove and Dominic Cummings led a brilliant campaign in 2016 outwitting Cameron and the hopelessly Eurofanatic Establishment – who can forget Sunderland declaring for Brexit and the die being cast? Moreover, he snookered Boris’ candidature for Tory Leader – had he penetrated Boris’ bluster and realised he did not have the requisite prime ministerial qualities?   



Uneasy political allies, but winners all. Gove, Johnson and Farage.

I rate Gove very highly and pay tribute to his talent and integrity in the rough old game of politics.

2.     Sir Keir Starmer

Keir Starmer is not really my cup of tea, but he is likely to be our next Prime Minister and he has some real merits. He is 61 years old and was born into a Labour-supporting family (father a toolmaker, mother a nurse) in Surrey; indeed, he was named Keir after Labour Party founder Keir Hardie – what a suffocating legacy for a child!



                            Keir Starmer

After education at one-time state school Reigate Grammar, now independent and fee-paying, he read law at Leeds and took a postgraduate DCL at St Edmund Hall, Oxford (my college 60 years ago, so he must be a good egg!). Admitted to the Bar, he specialised in criminal and human rights cases and rose in the legal profession being appointed Director of Public Prosecutions from 2008-13, for which he was awarded his knighthood. In 2013 he was wooed inevitably by the Labour Party, then under the leadership of uninspiring Ed Miliband and soon to be defeated in the polls by a resurgent David Cameron. Starmer became the MP for the safe Labour seat Holborn St Pancras in the general election of 2015.

The advent of the Jeremy Corbyn leadership of the Labour Party in 2016 ushered in a violent move to the hard Left (Corbyn a lifetime admirer of the former East Germany!), Wokery unbounded, shameful obeisance to the BLM agitation and all the insanity of utopian crypto-communism. Corbyn even got a boost from Theresa May’s misjudged snap general election in 2017. Starmer dutifully fulfilled Shadow roles, whatever he privately thought of Corbyn.

Corbyn’s Labour Party was duly thrashed by Boris Johnson’s Tories in December 2019 and Corbyn resigned as Leader. Starmer comfortably won the ensuing leadership election 2020. There was a purge of Corbynites and their dogmas, who had so damaged the Party and Starmer began to rebuild Labour into an electable entity. Starmer is a sensible barrister, without much political guile, who is successfully re-aligning Labour policy and rhetoric in a centrist direction. The inept weakness of the Tories under Johnson, Truss and Sunak has eased his path.

But Starmer has spoken out strongly against Labour’s bouts of anti-Semitism (his 2 children are being brought up in the Jewish religion by his wife Victoria), against tax and spend fantasies, against uncontrolled immigration, against Russia’s war in Ukraine and against the barbarity of Hamas. He even broke a Party hoodoo with some kind words for the blessed Margaret Thatcher’s attitudes. A promising omen for the future! He has done the country a service by bringing Labour back into the mainstream.

I will be much briefer with the remain 4 solid citizens!

3.     Suella Braverman


 

Suella has had a meteoric career, serving as Home Secretary 2022-23, after being Boris’ Attorney-General. She has an exotic background with a Hindu Indian father and a Mauritian Christian mother, who was a Tory councillor. She is married to an Israeli-born Jew and is herself a Buddhist, brought up in Wembley. Her rise to high office underlines the “inclusiveness” of our nation.

Suella is no respecter of convention and expresses her views with refreshing clarity and candour. She has challenged the pro-immigration lobby, favours deportation of boat people to Rwanda, supports pulling out of the European Convention on Human Rights (“all that Woke nonsense”), believes legal immigration is far too high and, no doubt like her erstwhile colleague Robert Jenrick, considers the Sunak government weak and indecisive on this vital issue.

She is a doughty and admirable right-wing Tory.

4.     Rachel Reeves



                                                                       Rachel Reeves

Starmer had the good sense to promote clever Rachel Reeves to Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer. Now resident in Leeds (Bramley), Rachel is the daughter of two teachers and her sister Ellie is also an MP. Born in Lewisham, Rachel read PPE at New College, Oxford and after a spell at HBOS, became an economist at the Bank of England.

She has identified herself as a believer in “securonomics” an airy Bidenesque concept, involving an interventionist state, strict control of government spending and taxes, and stimulants to business. Coupled with Rachel’s promise not to raise any personal taxes, this sounds quite promising. But politicians easily renege on promises, so we will probably see in time what substance underlies her professions of fiscal virtue.

5.     Penny Mordaunt



                           Penny holds the Sword of State at the Coronation in May 2023

Penny Mordaunt, aged 50, entered Parliament in 2010 and is now Lord President of the (Privy) Council, a Tory pin-up, who handles herself with commendable dignity. She has had a succession of ministerial positions and was briefly Liz Truss’ Defence Secretary. She is a socially liberal Brexiteer and is much identified with support for the armed forces and their charities. She represents a Portsmouth constituency and was herself in the Royal Naval Reserve. She has stood twice for the Tory Party leadership, probably a bridge too far. She is a quintessential modern Tory, wholly resistant to wokery, despite being a constant target of hostile social media.

6.     Frank Field.



                                                 A younger Frank Field

I have to be quick to fit in a tribute to Frank Field as the poor man is suffering from terminal cancer and is in hospice care. Frank was MP for Birkenhead for 40 years from 1979 to 2019 and then became a life peer on the crossbenches after leaving the Labour Party in 2018. Born in London of Tory working-class parents, he was originally a conservative but moved to Labour in 1960 due to Tory equivocation about opposing apartheid in South Africa.

He long championed Birkenhead (where my parents were married oddly enough) and Merseyside. Most of his political life has been devoted to the alleviation of poverty fortified by his Anglican Christian faith. He remained socially conservative, even as a minister, deploring the payment of benefits without any contributions and advocating a small state. He was a long-time friend of Margaret Thatcher. He was respected in Labour circles for his expertise in the minutiae of social policy and his energetic advocacy but his support for Brexit and opposition to immigration made him many enemies. Field resigned the Labour whip in 2018 protesting about “intolerance, nastiness and intimidation.”

Our system should be able better to nurture independent, maverick characters like Frank Field who contribute much to public life.

 

SMD

10.12.23

Text copyright © Sidney Donald 2023